|
Left-handed guitarists
have to make a choice between whether they want to play a regular right-handed
guitar or a left-handed guitar. There is no simple answer to this question
and unlike issues such as left-handed scissors there are legitimate questions
as to whether a left-handed guitar is easier for a left-handed player.
First it is necessary to examine why a standard right-handed guitar is
held in the direction of the neck pointing to the left. This tradition
of the guitar being held to the left like many of the traditions in guitar
comes from the classical guitar which was the dominant guitar style when
the guitar was being developed. Until the 20th century the guitar, both
classical and popular, was mostly played by finger-picking instead of
with a pick. In finger-style guitar both hands are performing complex
and difficult tasks but the finger-picking right hand is the one performing
the more complicated tasks. For this reason the right-hand was given the
finger-picking task and the left-hand the fretting task resulting in the
guitar pointing in the leftward direction.
In the last century, playing the guitar with a pick has become much more
popular and widespread to the point where there are far more players who
can play with a pick than with their fingers. Picking with a pick is a
much simpler procedure than finger-picking yet the direction of the guitar
has remained true to tradition. I would argue that theoretically for right-handed
guitarists who have no intention of finger-picking, it may actually make
more sense to play a left-handed guitar since the stronger right hand
would be the one doing the fretting which is more complex than picking
with the pick. Thus, I don't think that left-handed guitarists playing
with a pick are at any disadvantage playing a right-handed guitar and
may actually be at an advantage.
For guitarists who want to finger-pick or who think they may want to do
so in the future, the issue is more complex. While the finger-picking
hand is generally considered the more complex and difficult of the two
hands, both hands are performing complicated and difficult tasks. Any
advantage won by switching one task to the strong hand has its counterpart
in that the task performed in the other hand suffers an equal disadvantage.
The question is whether the advantage of having the strong hand for the
finger-picking hand outweighs the disadvantages of playing a left-handed
guitar. It should also be noted that there are many left-handed finger-pickers
who still pick very well even though they are finger-picking with the
right-hand.
The disadvantages of playing a left-handed guitar is that these guitars
are much harder to get and usually more expensive than their right-handed
counterparts. Many companies do not even make left-handed instruments
and those that do often only produce a limited number of their models
in left-handed versions. If you play left-handed you have to accept that
you may not be able to buy the exact guitar you want and even if you are
able to buy it you will probably have to pay more for it. While this may
seem unfair it does cost guitar manufacturers a significant amount of
money to change their machinery to produce left-handed guitars. Considering
that approximately 10% of the population is left-handed and that of those
left-handed guitar players probably more than 50% play right-handed guitars
the market for these guitars is limited. Additionally one has to consider
that guitar is one of the few instruments in which a left-handed version
is available. For example, although there are examples of left-handed
pianos they are extremely rare despite the fact that a left-handed pianist
is probably at more disadvantage playing a right-handed instrument than
a left-handed guitarist.
The major disadvantage to playing a left-handed guitar is not the lack
of instrument selection and cost but the fact that you will not be able
to play a standard guitar. Every time you are at a party and someone hands
you a guitar you will not be able to play it. If you want to play guitar
you will almost always have to have your own guitar around while if you
played a right-handed guitar you would be able to borrow other people's
guitars or use whatever guitar is lying around. Students that I have had
who have played left-handed guitars have told me that this is incredibly
frustrating.
I am not left-handed myself and am not advocating that all left-handed
players play right-handed guitars. I do, however, think that left-handed
beginning guitarists need to give some serious consideration to whether
there is any advantage to playing a left-handed guitar and whether this
advantage outweighs all of the disadvantages. Above all one should not
assume that because you are left-handed and there is a guitar that is
called left-handed it is necessarily better for you in the way that a
left-handed pair of scissors would be. I would recommend that any left-handed
person who is buying their first guitar try out both left and right-handed
guitars to find out which feels more comfortable. If the left-handed version
feels much better for you then it is probably better to play a left-handed
guitar. If you find there is no significant difference then it is probably
better to choose a right-handed guitar.
|